Callaway is known for making some of the best wedges on the market. Two of Callaway’s recent-ish releases, MD4 and MD5, have made waves in the golfing community as some of the best-performing models currently sold on the market. However, since they’re both so well-received, choosing between them can prove daunting – luckily, I’m here to help.
Callaway MD4 and MD5 are performance-improving wedges known for their ergonomically designed grooves which, although extremely helpful, still fall within USGA guidelines. However, the former has a firmer feel and is more durable than its counterpart, while the latter is softer and comes in more variations.
To learn more about these masterfully crafted wedges and decide which one would be best suited to you, make sure to read on. Below, I’ll go over some of their most notable differences, advantages, and drawbacks so that you can make a well-informed decision on which would be the better investment.
Callaway MD4 vs. MD5: Comparison Table
Here’s how the Callaway MD4 and Callaway MD5 wedges compare in terms of price point, finish options, feel, loft range, control, and feedback.
| Properties | Callaway MD4 | Callaway MD5 |
| Price Point | Moderate-High | High |
| Finish Options | Two Finishes: Chrome and Matte Black | Three Finishes: Chrome, Tour Grey, and Raw |
| Feel | Firmer | Softer |
| Loft Range | 46° – 60° | 46° – 64° |
| Control | High | Moderate |
| Feedback | Good | Excellent |
By reading through the table above, you’ve probably already created a pretty good idea of which option would be best suited to your playing style and handicap level. If not, I recommend crafting a list of all the features you’re looking for in your next wedge.
Then, check which ones you’ve prioritized the most and where they fall in the comparison table. That should give you a better idea of which model would serve you best. At the end of the day, both models feature ergonomic groves that are still acceptable by the USGA.
Before you make a final decision, though, make sure to read through each option’s advantages and drawbacks.
Callaway MD4
Here are the main pros and cons of the Callaway MD4 wedge:
Pros
- Increased pin on short shots.
- Extremely versatile.
- Very durable.
- Remarkable control.
- Great for lower handicappers.
Cons
- Expensive.
- Not the best choice for high handicappers.
- Not the best feeling.
Callaway MD5
On the other hand, here are the pros and cons of the Callaway MD5 wedge:
Pros
- Updated features and design elements.
- Comes in more finishes and a wider loft range.
- Excellent soft feel.
- Great for a wide range of handicap levels.
- Improved consistency.
Cons
- Though cheaper than its MD4 counterpart, the MD5 is still pricey.
- Not as durable as the MD4.
- Not the best choice for low handicappers.
Conclusion
As a golfer, you should always take your preferences, playing style, and handicap level into account when choosing any new equipment, and the decision between these two Callaway wedges is no different.
Both the MD4 and the MD5 are excellent-quality wedges designed to optimize control and spin; however, the former boasts a firmer feel and a more versatile grid, while the latter offers more updated features and improved feedback. Whether one’s better than the other will ultimately depend on the features you prioritize the most in your wedges.